Israel Museum
Israel Museum
Yesterday Kitat Maayan visited the Israel Museum. We started off our day by looking at part of Jerusalem's beautiful skyline. We talked about how the city's buildings had to be made out of Jerusalem stone and the ugly skyscraper in the middle of it all. After this we headed to an outdoor room, where we could see directly through a hole in the ceiling. Apparently this is a popular place to stargaze. As we sat in the beautiful stargazing area, we recapped the story of Hanukkah and how the Hasmoneans became Kings and high Priests. We discussed our Jewish state at the time and how even though the Hasmoneans fought for our freedom from the Greeks, they still named their children Greek names. We then discussed how we fell under Roman rule. Alexandria Salome ruled at the time. Alexandria had 2 sons, Hyrcanus 1 and Astrobolus 2. They struggled for power within the dynasty. This caused a civil war. Eventually Hyrcanus went to the Romans, his allies for help. This was a big mistake. Unfortunately, this is how we lost control of our freedom. In 63 BCE Roman presence came about. Hyrcanus ruled as a puppet king or in other words a king who was being controlled by the Romans. Similarly, King Herod הורדוס ruled the same way. King Herod married into the dynasty and was not fully Jewish. He was an extraordinary builder. People were afraid of him. He killed members of his own family to show his power. He also ruled by way of 'carrot and stick'. In theory the carrot was the temple or the reward and the army was the stick or the punishment. We spoke about how different rabbis saw the Roman Empire. Some saw it as a good thing. The Romans were providing for us. Others saw that the Romans were doing all this for themselves.
Next we stopped at the אהבת exhibit for a quick photo shoot. After getting a few good shots in front of the infamous sign, we visited the model of the old city. I found this to be quite impressive. The model itself made to scale 1-50. It was made in 1960 by a man named by Avi-Yonah. He used 4 main sources to create his model. The most important was archaeological findings of the Old City. The second was the description of temple in the mishnah. He compared the architecture of the old city to that of the Roman cities. And lastly he used the writings of Yosef Ben Matityahu, a Jew who eventually fought for the Romans and wrote scriptures for them. We discussed the characteristics of the Old City while looking at the model. The city expanded from David outward. Every time the population would grow, the city would have to expand its limits. The poorer people lived in the lower part of the city to the west of David. They lived in small houses and were very crowded. Even further west is the upper city. This was the wealthier sect of the city. Jewish Romans lived there. There was a shuk and possibly a theater (although we aren't quite sure where). King Harod's palace was also located in this part of the city. King Harod built an amazing plaza all around the second temple. All people were allowed here. Next to the plaza and temple was a fortress where soldiers watched over this spot (and King Harod).
(shows the entire model)
Next we discussed Sectarian Judaism. These are the different types of Jews that existed at the time. We talked about the differences between the four major sects Judaism and had Nina, Sara, Becca, and Goldie demonstrate for us. The 1st sect is Sadducees צדוקים. These were the richest of Jews, most of them kohanim (priests at the Temple). They were apart of high Roman society. They practiced Judaism regularly (as did most Jews, there was no such thing as orthodox or secular). They took everything in Torah very literally. By this I mean they did not interpret the Torah. They adopted Roman culture but kept their religion. The second sect was Pharisees פרושים. These were poorer Jews in the Jerusalem. They lived in the lower city. They practiced gratitude through prayer. They were rabbis so they felt obligated to the Torah but they still interpreted it. They lived in simple homes and worked as shoemakers and wood cutters. They did not conform to Hellenistic culture. They adapted to the new Roman culture. The third sect was the Zealots. These were Jewish warriors who fought for independence. They lived in the lower city and rebelled against the Romans. They believed in interpretation of Torah as well. They were against Roman rule. The 4th sect was the Essenes איסיים. These Jews did not live in Jerusalem. They lived in the dead sea area. They rejected Hellenistic culture. They studied, meditated, and copied ancient texts. They were obsessed with ritual bathing or mikveh. They believed messiah was coming soon and avoided the Romans all together.
(shows the vast lower city in the middle and on the bottom right the city of David)
Some people even believe that the Dead Sea Scrolls could have come from the Essenes.
The scrolls were our next stop. The Dead Sea Scrolls were found in 1947 in a cave near the Dead Sea. They date back to around 200 BCE - 70 CE, which is around when the temple was destroyed. The Dead Sea Scrolls were divided into two types. The first type was biblical, where they had nearly every book of the Tanakh. The second type is communal. These talked about the Dead Sea cult, the Yechad, and how everything was owned by the people. We saw the Aleppo Codex from the 14th century which was the oldest Tanakh before the finding of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Then, we saw a nano Tanakh, which I found quite impressive (fun fact! A nano Tanakh was given to President Obama after visiting Israel)! After seeing the smallest Tanakh ever, we walked outside and discussed these monumental art exhibits.
(Represents darkness and death)
My question for you all is do you think King Harod was a good leader? Explain. And if you were to live during the time period of King Herod and the Roman presence, what sect of Judaism would you fall under and why?






I believe that King Herod was a good leader. He may have been paranoid about revolts and uprisings, but he was a good leader and made the Jews happy. He used the carrot and stick method of ruling and was a puppet king. He also did some bad things, but he covered his bases. I believe I would be in the Sect of the Pharisees. There was an adaptation to the Roman culture and based on the person I am, I would want to fit in instead of standing out. I also would want to pray anywhere I want instead of just in the Beit Hamikdash. I loved you blog! Great job!
ReplyDeleteI think King Herod was an average leader. He was overly paranoid about everything and that led him to do bad things but overall he gave the Jews what they needed. I think that I would be a part of the Pharisees sect. I say that because if I was alive during that time, I think that the Pharisees beliefs of, questioning the Torah, and adapting to the Roman culture is something that I would have wanted and would have seemed most fitting for the survival of the Jewish people as a whole.
ReplyDeleteTo me, King Herod was not a good ruler. In the end, he wasn't really the leader anyways. I mean sure, he's done some pretty great stuff architecture and with keeping the Jewish people happy. But he's not truly the leader, the romans are. As we have said many times in class, he is the "Puppet Ruler," which just means that the Romans are whispering into his ear what to do. I feel like I would fall under the sect of the Pharisees, which makes sense because they are our ancestors. When a problem occurs, I often try to avoid it instead of confront it head on, so that eliminates the zealots. I do not take torah word to word, so that eliminates the Sadducees. And even though I would avoid a problem, I would not run from it, but rather continue to live my life as it was, so we can also eliminate the Essenes.
ReplyDeleteKing Herod, as crazy as was did some good things for his people. He created great architecture, and although the romans were truly the rulers, he did a good job at being one. I think that if i was one of the four sects, I would be the Pharisees. When I first read about them I felt a connection with them, and their lives. Culturally and Religiously the way they run there lives is the way I feel at some times and who I wish I could be sometimes. I truly admire them.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteExcellent blog Lily and great comments guys! Just a small correction, the Pharisees adapted to Roman rule, but they did not accept Roman culture at this point in time!!! So would you be more of a Sadducee or a Pharisee?
ReplyDeleteI thought that this was an amazing tiyul. It was so interesting to learn about the different Jewish peoples. It was odd to hear that the people followed the same religion, but had totally different views. This can be compared to today where we have the Ultra Orthodox to the Reform. Do you think that we would unite today to fight a power threatening our religion?
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure if King Herod was a good leader or not. He was paranoid and "a puppet ruler", but at the same had built amazing fortresses and had done many good things. If I had to choose what sect I would be in, I think I would have been a Pharisee. Judaism is the most important part of my life, and I love to pray (and it doesn't have to be necessarily in the synagogue). And in general, their lifestyle is the one I'm the closest to and the one I would want to have in the future.
ReplyDeleteIt is my belief that King Herod is not a good leader. His "carrot and stick" method of ruling was effective yet harsh. Herod's paranoia made him crazy and because of this would murder others. If for no other reason, Herod can be in no way a good leader because his actions go against two of the three Kidush Hashem (murder and avoda zara). Great blog post Lily!
ReplyDeleteKing Herod wasn't much of a ruler. He really just did random things to get favor and likeness from the jewish people. He was a bad leader in that he let the Romans run all over the jewish people. He one thing that no jew would ever do. He murdered people.
ReplyDeleteOne thing that stuck out to me about King Herod is that he let everyone in the plaza of the second temples... Although I believe that that's how it's supposed to be regardless of wether people want diversion or not, things were pretty separated at this time. That being said, I do not think that King Herod was a good leader... Herod did cruel things, such as kill members of his own family just for power, which is just despicable. If someone kills their own family just to gain power, what will they do once they get in power? If I was able to live under King Heroes rule and the roman time period I would be part of the Essenes because I share similar beliefs as them, I love nature and although I'm Jewish... I'm not so strict about it. I like how the Essenes are unique and have their own twist to being Jewish, they also come in peace.
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure how I feel about King Herod. On one hand he was able to build so many amazing buildings. On the other hand he was barely a ruler and was extremely powerful. If I lived during this time I would probably live under the Essenes way because I agree with their beliefs and the way in which they live.
ReplyDeleteKing Herod could have been a lot worse. He could have straight up banned assemblies or militarized the temple mount itself. Instead he BUILT the temple mount, and placed a nearby citadel to cover his ass. In a time full of constant political and religious change, Herod could have done a lot worse than be a jerk every now and then.
ReplyDeleteI do not think King Herod is a leader that should stand out in Judaism other than for his extraordinary building skills. Everything that he did was because he was paranoid and he wanted to protect his own power rather than coming from a place where he cared for the jewish people. This was most likely because he was not jewish in a way that was meaningful to him as it was because his father was forcefully converted.
ReplyDeleteIf I was a jew during the time of roman rule, I would most likely be a sadduce because I believe that there are many parts of an identity, and that it is quite alright to absorb from the cultures around you because aspects of every culture are beautiful. It is also realistically what I am most similar to as an American Jew.