Masada

At 4:15 in the morning, the students of Heller High began their day. After grabbing a bagged lunch and a few announcements, we began our hike in the dark to the base of Masada. At the base, we prepared ourself for the challenge of the next hour.



The hike up Masada was one of the most challenging things I have ever done, since I have exercise-induced asthma. The hike started off fine, in fact I found myself leading the group for the first half. We were singing songs, cracking jokes, and telling stories. However, that enthusiasm did not last. As the night turned to dusk, the temperature grew, along with the aching of my legs. I found myself stopping every minute to take a breath. I remember my heart pounding through my chest and the struggle I had to keep a beat as I breathed. I was soon in the back of the group, and people had to wait for me before they could continue. It was the encouragement of my classmates, teachers, and complete strangers that kept me going.


I made it to the top of Masada two minutes before sunrise. I joined my classmates and we all watched the amazing sunrise as we still healed from our hike. I remember the cheers and the complete change of mood as the sun rose, everyone realizing where they were and what they just accomplished.

After watching the sunrise, we had a beautiful tefillah service and split into our two groups.

The word Masada (מצדה) in Hebrew translates to "the fortress" in english. This makes perfect sense, since it is high up on a plateau so it is safe from danger, and it can also keep an eye out on the world around it.


The first stop that we went to was the Northern tip of the mountain, this is where King Herod would reside as he wished.  We looked at a replica of his palace, and then took a group picture.King Herod had the goal that the people on Masada could live on the top for ten years without coming down for supplies. By doing so, he made a few necessary modifications. First, he dug trenches from Mt. Chevron to Masada so that there was a reliable water source. Next, he added twenty-nine storage units to hold items such as dried fruits and weapons. A third, and not as necessary modification was the construction of his palace. Herod's palace, facing north in order to get a cool breeze, had three main layers to it. The top layer was the palace itself, or where the King lived.  The second layer was the spot where Herod would entertain, often to his Roman and Jewish guests.  And the bottom layer was a guest house, equipped with a bath house.  


At the end of the Great Revolt, the Zealots from Jerusalem (warrior sect) fled to Masada.  They did this because zealots have been living at Masada already for a few years before.  The first battle of the Great Revolt was in fact the battle where the Zealots took Masada from the Romans.  They were able to do this by climbing up the side of the mountain, vowing that if they fell they would do so quietly.  They picked Masada because they knew that it was a place where they could sustain life for a long period of time.  

When the Zealots conquered Masada, they put in a few additions to make it seem more like home.  First, they added many Mikvehs, but they did it for other reasons than praying at the temple.  The main reason for the mikveh is for women to bathe in it after their menstrual cycle, since it is an interaction with death.  They did this so that the Jewish people could reproduce.  Another addition to Masada was a synagogue.  The synagogue was built so that the Jewish people would sit facing each other, building sense of community.  Also, although it was already there, they made sure that the art in the bath house was kosher, or doesn’t have any figures on it.  They did this so that they could sustain Jewish life and keep Judaism alive.  Within this is the vision of the dry bones.  The vision of the dried bones is how the Jewish people will rise up again from their ashes, and God will breathe air back into them.  




Eventually, the Romans got their revenge.  They surrounded Masada and built a ramp in order to siege the top. However, when the Romans got to the top, they found that all 960 inhabitants of Masada were dead, according to Josephus Flavius.    It is very hard to understand their actions, but many people have tried to infer why they did what they did.  One reason why they might have killed themselves is because they did not want to become slaves as they were in Egypt, and they were celebrating the holiday of Passover.  The Rabbi’s at the time did not recognize the fall of Masada.  All though we do not for sure know why the rabbis do not recognize it, there are a few inferences.  The first reason is that they did not condemn or approve of what the Zealots did, because it was going against the ten commandments.  A second reason is because they did not want to say something terrible about Masada.  The third reason is that they didn’t write out of respect. But once again, we are not sure why, it is all speculation.  

Today, we often vow to “not let Masada fall again.”  By saying this, it shows that the Jewish people will fight through thick and thin in order to preserve their land and their religion.  To me, Masada represents the land of Israel and by saying that we will never let Masada fall again, we will not let Israel fall again.


My question for Kitaat Maayan is this:  I interpret the acts of bravery that took place at the top of Masada as doing ultimate sacrifices for what you are passionate about.  What are some things that you are passionate about, and what are you willing to sacrifice in order to keep them?  Are there some things you would sacrifice nothing for? Are there some things you would die for?

Comments

  1. Some of the things I am most passionate about are social justice, photography, and seeing the world. Whether it's using my photos to show awareness, learning about social justice and taking action, or traveling the world so I can learn about all the different cultures and insights all individuals have to offer; I use all of these to somehow make the world a better place. I'm willing to sacrifice many things in order to make this world a better place such as giving up my belongings or risking my life to help those in need. The only things I would not sacrifice anything for would be movements and individuals who mistreat others and put people down.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think dying for ideas and human constructs are never worth. Human life is worth more than anything on Earth and the decision to end it for someone is with insane importance. To kill yourselves for not committing a sin against God to me is absolutely crazy. I would never sacrifice my life for any idea or relationship, no matter how much I cared about it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that there are very few thing I would die for. The main being my family. If i had to die to keep any one or all of my 4 immediate family members alive, I would do it in an instant. But I don't understand why the zealots killed themselves when they could at least tried to defeat the romans. Who know, another David vs Goliath battle could go in the Jews favor.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is a wonderful post. In both the business and education worlds, when we talk about values that we are not willing to give up, that we would go to the mat for or would leave an organization if they changed or abandoned them, we are talking about core values. They are the unchanging values that inform who we are and what we are about and why we are motivated to do what we do.

    For example, personal integrity is a core value for me. I will not work for an organization that requires me to sacrifice my personal integrity in any way. I would rather leave, even if it meant being out of work for an extended period of time, than sacrifice my personal integrity.

    I think you raise excellent, challenging and important questions. Keep asking them!

    Kol HaKavod!

    ReplyDelete
  5. One thing I am passionate about making sure the future good for me and the people that I love. I would sacrifice a lot for that. I think that knowing that my family and friends are going to be okay for however long they will be with me is a big thing and very meaningful if something you did could help with that. I would die for my friends or family, because they are things that are very important to me and I want to know that they can live there lives to the fullest. I would sacrifice nothing for things that are harming me or the people I surround myself with.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with Nina, I am very passionate about my future, and I would do whatever it takes to be content with myself and my life and have a roof over my head. When I'm older I want to design and build the house I live in but that takes a lot of time, effort and money but if you want something the only way you can achieve that goal is by getting up and working for it. When I'm older I will also probably juggle jobs. I also am passionate about my family...but I would not die for anyone in my family or not in my family because I wouldn't want someone to end their lives just for me and I hope that they would feel the same. I agree with Jeremy, human life is just too important.

    ReplyDelete
  7. One thing I am passionate about is music, family, drawing, and my friends. I would do so much for all of my family and friends. I am a people-pleaser and I please people almost to an unhealthy situation, which isn't always good. Nonetheless, that shows that I would do so much for the people around me. Human life is too valuable. Dying for ideas and morals seems a bit extreme for me.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Some things that I am passionate about are music, NFTY, and my future. For these things I would sacrifice so much, because these three things are what make me happy and what make me me. I don't know if i would die for anything, but if i would, i would probably die for my family.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'm passionate about family. Family, to me, is the most important part of life, and knowing that by sacrificing something for my family would do things better, I'm willing to do it. Baruch Hashem, I haven't had any reasons to sacrifice anything, but if I had to do ANYTHING to make my mom and brothers happier, I would do it.

    ReplyDelete
  10. There are many things that I am passionate about but very few I would die for. The only things I would ever risk my life for would be my friends or immediate family. I don't think I would ever be in such a position to have to make this choice and I am very grateful for that. However, if I was put in this situation my family and friends would be the things I would die for.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am passionate about my friends and family and I would like to think that I would be willing to make the ultimate sacrifice for them, if I were ever in that situation. There are other things like cheerleading that I love and I am very passionate about, but I wouldn't die for them. I would make other smaller sacrafices for things like this. I quit playing soccer to continue more seriously with my cheerleading career. More recently, I quit cheerleading to come to Israel for a semester. These have to do with my priorities and what I think is most important. There are other things that I wouldn't make sacrafices for. For example, I wouldn't give up doing something I love in order to please other people.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I love my friends and family. I would be more than willing to sacrifice my life for those close to me. Ideologically, I really don't know what I would be willing to die for. I guess I can't say for sure what I would be willing to die for. The only thing I can think of is if my freedoms were being infringed upon. I perceive this type of infraction the same way I perceive the threat of my family being harmed; something I cannot live with, in which case the only other option is death.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I would only be willing to sacrifice myself in this manner if I knew my death would be continuing a cause that I am passionate about. I think that the sacrifice at Masada is something which only guaranteed that the fight they were fighting for would not live on, but I guess I understand that they felt they had no other option. I think more of them should have tried to escape and die trying that just kill one another. That being said, I would sacrifice myself for my friends or family, to protect someones individual freedom, or for a cause I know i would be continuing in a significant way. I am also passionate about politics, helping people who cannot help themselves, and writing. I also want to be a lawyer, so it is important to me to protect the justice system.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Great post Dani! I remember that feeling of success when I arrived to the top and seeing the beautiful sunrise. Something that I'm passionate about are my friends. I would do anything to help them and keep them happy and healthy as they would do for me. I have an internal argument with myself on occasion and it is this: (god forbid) would I save my best friends from mortal danger even if its laying my own life down? I would like to think so, but when I think deeper into the matter I realize the sickening thought that I wouldn't protect them. A follow up question is how could I sleep at night knowing I couldn't save him? Of course these are dark thoughts and probably something like this will never happen, but once in a while I have these debates with myself to test my morals.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

2nd Temple, Herodian Mansions and Southern Wall

Tykocin Blog

Streams of Judaism Tiyuul/